Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil Review
Sean
I tested Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil for two weeks. Read my review here to learn how my beard felt after using it. What I liked and didn’t like, and if a widely disliked aspect of the oil was also an issue for me.
Introduction
Following my test of Cremo Heritage Red Beard Oil, I switched to Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil exclusively for two weeks. I followed the same application steps as with my previous tests.

Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil
A Refresher on Beard Oil Basics
Beard oil is a product that nourishes both beard hair and the skin underneath. It provides moisture to keep the beard soft, reduce itching, and strengthen beard hairs. Many beard oils also include ingredients that make your beard smell nice.
See How to Use Beard Oil for beard oil application instructions.
My Two-Week Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil Test
I followed the same consistent method I am currently using for all my beard oil reviews.
I used the Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil daily and made sure my beard was wet before application.
I started with 5 to 6 drops of the Honest Amish beard oil. By the end of the test, I reduced this to 3 to 4 drops. This is a heavy oil blend, so fewer drops were needed.
I focused on working the oil into the skin under my beard instead of the hair. Focusing on the skin still ensures enough oil gets onto the beard. I use my fingertips to work the oil deep into the beard and onto the skin.
I used a boar bristle brush to work the oil into my beard. This also provides some light exfoliation of the skin under the beard.
I repeated this process daily for two weeks.
Results: Beard Health & Feel
Honest Amish has a reputation for producing quality beard oils and I now see why. This oil is the best I’ve tried so far. It warms up nicely in my hands when I rub them together and feels great in my beard. My beard hair feels better than with any other oil I’ve tried in the past.
Let’s Talk About The Smell
The smell of Honest Amish products is a common complaint. I would describe the smell of the premium beard oil as “different”. It’s an unusual, earthy, spicy smell. Before application, it almost smells more like a cooking ingredient than a beard care product. I suspect this is due to the Virgin Black Organic Cumin Oil, listed as the first ingredient.
The good news is it doesn’t really smell like that in my beard. I asked my wife to tell me what she smelled immediately after I applied it, and her description was just a “fresh” or “clean” scent. However, it is clear to me that the smell may not be appealing to many beard oil users. Especially those that prefer a more cologne-like smell.
The quality of the oil is amazing and I would highly recommend it, but I would also recommend seeing if you can find someone that already has a bottle. Then you can smell it before buying to make sure you will like it.
After two weeks, I have grown to like the smell. I have also worn the oil to social gatherings to see if anyone would comment on or react to the smell. So far, no one has said anything. I’m switching to a beard wash review next, so I plan to continue using this oil to reduce variability in product testing. I will continue to use this oil and will post and update here if anyone comments on the smell.
Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil Ingredients
The Honest Amish packaging states “Hand Crafted From The Finest Organic Oils” and “Nothing Artificial”. Reading the ingredients list this appears to be true.
The ingredients listed on the box the bottle came in and the bottle itself are different. I am basing my review on the ingredients listed on the bottle.
The Honest Amish ingredients list consists of 10 items. The same as the previously reviewed Cremo oil. My opinion is that, when it comes to anything going in or on your body, fewer ingredients is better. If all of the ingredients listed are familiar and easily recognizable, or at least recognizable from an internet search of their scientific names, that’s even more appealing to me. Honest Amish lists every ingredient by its common name. There are no vague or concealed ingredients like “fragrance” or “parfum”.
Six of the ten ingredients on the bottle are listed as a “Virgin” oil. This means the oil was extracted using mechanical and physical means only. No heat or chemical solvents were used.
The first ingredient—Virgin Black Cumin Oil—is also known as simply Black Seed Oil. According to both Typology and Mission Beard, this oil moisturizes and softens beard hair.
The next three ingredients-Virgin Avocado Oil, Golden Jojoba Oil, and Virgin Argan Oil are all well-known and highly beneficial carrier oils.
Reminder: Always do a patch test before trying a new product on your skin, and read the ingredients list carefully.
Finally I think it’s important to point out that the oil arrived with an allergy warning stating that the product contains fruit and nut butters and oils. As with all products, read the ingredients list carefully and conduct a patch test before using.
Price Point
The Honest Amish web site lists a 2 oz bottle of the premium oil at $19.77 US. This is a little higher than some oils, but not too bad considering the quality of the ingredients. For comparison, a 1 oz bottle of Cremo Heritage Red Beard Oil is $10.97. So, per ounce, the Honest Amish oil is still less expensive.
Pros
- Made my beard feel noticeably softer and more hydrated after just a few uses.
- Contains high-quality, mostly virgin and organic oils — no artificial ingredients or fillers.
- A little goes a long way. By the end of the test I was using fewer drops and still getting great results.
- Priced fairly for the quality — about $19.77 for a 2 oz bottle, which is still cheaper per ounce than some competitors.
- Ingredient list is clear and uses plain names, which makes it easy to understand what’s actually in it.
- Once applied, the scent softens into a clean, natural smell that others described as “fresh.”
Cons
- The scent right out of the bottle is unusual — earthy and spicy, likely from the black cumin oil.
- The smell takes some getting used to. It grew on me, but it might not for everyone.
- The ingredients on the box didn’t exactly match what’s printed on the bottle — minor, but worth noting.
- Slightly higher upfront price than some brands, though the bottle size offsets that.
Notes: If possible, try smelling a bottle before buying or buy from a store with a lenient return policy. The scent is unique, and not everyone will love it. Always apply to a damp beard and start with just a few drops, focusing on the skin first. My review is based on the bottle’s ingredient list, since it differed slightly from what’s printed on the box.
Final Thoughts
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5)
My beard felt amazingly soft and hydrated after two weeks of consistent use. I understand now why Honest Amish is such a highly regarded product. The biggest negative is the unusual smell. It definitely took me some time to get used to it.
Update (11/17/2025): I continued to use the Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil for two more weeks after completing this review. The experience remained unchanged after four weeks. The unusual scent remained the only issue during the additional two weeks of use. It will remain in my rotation while I continue to test and compare products.
Update (05/09/2026): After trying the premium beard oil, I became interested in trying other Honest Amish beard oils to see how they compared to both the premium oil and oils from other brands. I tested the Honest Amish Classic and the Honest Amish Pure Unscented beard oils and wrote a comparison of Classic vs Premium vs Pure Unscented.