Honest Amish Beard Oils Comparison: Classic vs Premium vs Pure Unscented

Sean

What’s the difference between the Classic, Premium and Pure Unscented versions of Honest Amish beard oil? Based on my own experience, here are the key differences.

Reminder: Always do a patch test before trying a new product on your skin, and read the ingredients list carefully.

Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil

Honest Amish Classic Beard oil is probably where many people start with Honest Amish. This oil is a blend of seven oils and seven essential oils. This is my favorite of the Honest Amish beard oils. I find it to have a pleasant scent, with earthy and spicy notes. Clove and anise are the most prominent scents from the essential oil blend. I like the scent of clove, but there may be readers that do not. The inclusion of seven essential oils may make this version less ideal for men with sensitive skin.

Honest Amish product bottle with dropper — Classic Beard Oil

Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil

The first two ingredients are extra virgin organic pumpkin seed oil and refined organic avocado oil. Pumpkin seed oil is a very effective carrier oil, and avocado oil provides deep nourishment for beard hair.

This oil is best for users looking for a product that provides both scent and moisturizing qualities, and that like the spicy, clove-forward scent profile.

Read my full review of Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil for more information.

Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil

Honest Amish Premium Beard oil is a blend of high quality, mostly virgin and organic olive oils. The oil itself is one of the best I’ve used. It’s exceptionally good at hydrating and moisturizing. However, the scent is not for everyone, including me.

Honest Amish product bottle with dropper — Premium Beard Oil

Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil

The first two ingredients are virgin organic apricot kernel oil and virgin organic avocado oil. Apricot kernel oil is a deep moisturizer, and avocado oil provides deep nourishment for beard hair.

This oil is best for those that find benefit from the specific ingredients found in this oil blend and don’t mind the odd scent.

Read my full review of Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil for more information.

Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard Oil

Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard oil is identical to the Classic beard oil without the seven essential oils. This was originally my favorite of the Honest Amish beard oils, but the Classic version has recently become my favorite. I like the simple ingredients. The exclusion of the essential oils may make this a good option for men with sensitive skin.

Like the Classic beard oil, the first two ingredients are extra virgin organic pumpkin seed oil and refined organic avocado oil. Pumpkin seed oil is a very effective carrier oil, and avocado oil provides deep nourishment for beard hair.

Honest Amish product bottle with dropper — Pure Unscented Beard Oil

Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard Oil

This oil is best for everyday use for its nourishing and moisturizing properties and for men with sensitivities to essential oils.

Read my full review of Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard Oil for more information.

Final Thoughts

I hope sharing my experience with these three products helped summarize the primary differences between them. You can read the full reviews by following the links posted earlier, or browse the full list of product reviews if you’re looking for more information on beard care and men’s grooming products.

The content on this site is based on my personal experience using and testing men’s grooming products, including beard care products such as oils, washes, balms, and related tools (e.g., trimmers and clippers). All reviews and opinions are my own.
Products may perform differently depending on factors such as skin type, hair type, grooming routine, and individual sensitivities. What works well for me may not work the same for you.
I am not a dermatologist, chemist, or medical professional. Any information provided about ingredients, product performance, or grooming practices is for informational purposes only and should not be considered medical advice. Always review ingredient lists carefully and perform a patch test before using new products, especially if you have sensitive skin or allergies.
Some posts may contain affiliate links. This means I may earn a small commission if you make a purchase through those links, at no additional cost to you. These commissions help support the site. I only recommend products I have personally used or believe provide value.
Whenever possible, I test products using a consistent, real-world routine and aim to highlight both strengths and drawbacks. However, all conclusions are subjective and based on my individual experience.
Always do your own research and use your best judgment when selecting grooming products.