I Tested Seven Beard Oils Available at Big-Box Stores. Here are the Oils I'm Keeping and How I Rank All Seven Brands.

From September of 2025 through February of 2026, I tested seven beard oils available at big-box stores. I tested each beard oil for a period of at least two weeks, carefully observing the effect each oil had on my beard.

Why Oils Available at Big-Box Stores?

I am a conscious consumer. I would prefer to shop local or from smaller brands if I can. However, I tested these oils from big-box store brands for one very important reason: this is where a lot of men start with beard oils. In my experience, I started with Walmart because it was convenient. I was already there to buy other items. I knew very little about beard oils back then. I just picked brands that sounded like what I needed based on reading the product packaging. Another common scenario is maybe someone buys you beard oil as a gift. Unless a recommendation for a boutique, small-batch brand is given, the gift giver may just go to a place like Walmart or Target and buy something off the shelf. Since a lot of men start with these brands carried at big-box stores, I decided to review my first round of beard oils from brands available at these stores.

A Note on 7 Beard Oils

All you really need to start with is one bottle of good beard oil that works for you. That one bottle will last one to two years. You don’t need to buy multiple bottles unless you want a different scent profile every now and then. I bought and reviewed seven beard oils because the main intent of my blog is to review beard care and men’s grooming products, and then share my experiences with others. You don’t need to buy that many bottles of beard oil. They will likely go bad before you ever have a chance to use them. I’m keeping 3 of the oils I reviewed. Three bottles is enough. Because beard oil lasts such a long time, I am going to have to stop my reviews of beard oils and focus on other products until I need to buy more oil. Even then, I may just buy my number one pick from the list again.

7 Beard Oils

#1 Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard Oil

Coming in at number one is Honest Amish Pure Unscented. As far as how my beard felt after two weeks of use, this was the winner. My beard felt full, healthy and strong. There were other oils with similar results as far as beard health, but they each had prominent negatives that bumped them out of the top three. This has now become my “everyday use” oil, and is the current “gold standard” that I use for evaluating beard oils.

Full review: Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard Oil Review

#2 Dr. Squatch Conditioning Beard Oil and Cologne - Glacial Falls

Landing in the number two spot is Dr. Squatch Conditioning Beard Oil and Cologne - Glacial Falls. This oil gave me the best combination of health and scent. This oil has my favorite scent of all the oils I tested. I wear this when I want to wear a scented oil. This has now become my favorite “going out” oil. Dr. Squatch was acquired by Unilever in 2025, and some Dr. Squatch fans have commented on a drop in quality of Dr. Squatch products. I have no previous experience to draw from as far as Dr. Squatch beard oils, as I bought and reviewed this oil in late 2025. It will be interesting to watch and see how the Dr. Squatch beard oils change over time under the Unilever umbrella.

Full review: Dr. Squatch Conditioning Beard Oil and Cologne - Glacial Falls Review

#3 Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil

Rounding out the top three by rating is Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil. Like other Honest Amish oils, this oil provided excellent beard health and feel. However, the inclusion of seven essential oils dropped it to third place in the rankings. While I appreciate the transparency, and even though I don’t have sensitive skin, I’m concerned about skin irritation from the number of essential oils. For this reason, I decided not to keep this oil, even though it ranked higher than the next oil in the list.

Full review: Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil Review

#4 Cremo Heritage Red Beard Oil

In the #4 spot is Cremo Heritage Red Beard Oil. This wasn’t a bad oil overall. While it didn’t provide the same feel as some of the other oils, I really like the Spiced Amber scent. Even though it ranked lower on the rating score than the Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil, I’m keeping this one around for a change of scent profile. However, I plan to use it sparingly because the scent is a little on the strong side. I prefer a subtler scent.

Full review: Cremo Heritage Red Beard Oil Review

#5 Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil

In the #5 spot is Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil. This oil is an interesting case. If I was ranking this list of oils purely on nourishing qualities like moisturizing and conditioning, then this oil would absolutely land in the #1 spot. Unfortunately, it’s hindered by its very odd smell. That one reason alone dropped this oil to #5 on the list.

Full review: Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil Review

#6 Every Man Jack Beard Oil - Sandalwood

In the #6 spot is Every Man Jack Beard Oil - Sandalwood. I like the Every Man Jack Sandalwood scent, but I found this beard oil to be too heavy and greasy for me. I have naturally oily skin, so an oil that leaves my beard feeling oily and greasy is just too much.

Full review: Every Man Jack Beard Oil - Sandalwood Review

#7 Beard Guyz Beard Oil

In the #7 spot is Beard Guyz Beard Oil. This oil had a pleasant scent and felt pretty good in my beard. However, when I took a closer look at the ingredients, I noticed the inclusion of denatured alcohol. This ingredient is considered harmful to beard hair. For this reason, this oil ranks #7 on my list. If you need something quick to resolve an issue like minor irritation/itching from new beard growth, you could use this in a pinch. Otherwise, I would not recommend it for long-term use.

Full review: Beard Guyz Beard Oil Review

The Beard Oils I’m Keeping

After testing all seven oils, I kept these bottles for regular use:

• Honest Amish Pure Unscented Beard Oil (My favorite for everyday use)
• Dr. Squatch Glacial Falls (Best combination of feel and scent)
• Honest Amish Classic Beard Oil (Nice clove-forward scent)
• Cremo Heritage Red Beard Oil (I scent I enjoy from time to time) - This was one of the first oils I reviewed and it did eventually start losing its scent after about 1.5 years and needed to be thrown away.
• Honest Amish Premium Beard Oil (The scent isn’t my favorite, but it’s a great moisturizer)

You really only need one or two bottles of good beard oil. I only have this many from conducting product reviews.

Final Ranking of the 7 Beard Oils

• Beard Oil
• Beard Products
• Beard Health
• Product Reviews